Journal of Applied Economics in Developing Countries
Vol 1, No 1 (2014): Journal of Applied Economics in Developing Countries

ARE GOVERNMENT BANKS LESS COMPETITIVE THAN PRIVATE BANKS? EVIDENCE FROM INDONESIAN BANKING

Tri Mulyaningsih (Universitas Sebelas Maret)
Anne Daly (University of Canberra)
Phil Lewis (University of Canberra)
Riyana Miranti (University of Canberra)



Article Info

Publish Date
09 Jul 2024

Abstract

Literature suggests that compared to private banks, state-owned banks have lower incentives to maximize profit. This study aims to investigate the possible different competitive behaviour of state-owned banks and private banks. The recent refinement of Panzar-Rosse method by Bikker, Shaffer, and Spierdijk (2011) was employed to estimate the competitive behaviour of state-owned and private banks. The empirical estimation of Fixed-Effect approach shows that the H-statistics of the state-owned banks was significantly smaller than of the private banks. It implies that private banks behaved more competitively than the state-owned banks. The private bank market was close to perfect competition or monopolistic competition where bank products are regarded as perfect substitutes for one another. In contrast, state-owned banks attempted to collude rather than to compete to generate a maximum profit. State-owned banks behaved less competitive because they served the interest of government or politician, have a long hierarchical organisational design, receive an interest rate subsidies and an implicit guarantee from government against failure and their business are being controlled by government.Keywords: Bank ownership, competitive behaviour, Panzar-Rosse

Copyrights © 2014






Journal Info

Abbrev

jaedc

Publisher

Subject

Economics, Econometrics & Finance

Description

FOCUS This journal focused on economics, business, and management in developing countries studies and presents developments through the publication of articles and research reports. SCOPE The Journal of Applied Economics in Developing Countries (JAEDC) specializes on Economics, Business, and ...