JAMP : Jurnal Administrasi dan Manajemen Pendidikan
Vol 8, No 3 (2025): Volume 8 No 3 September 2025

Principal Supervision in Indonesia: A Scoping Review of Models, Approaches and Educational Outcomes

Adimiharja Kusumadipraja (Indonesian Education University)
Diding Nurdin (Indonesian Education University)
Juliani Musti Khofifah (Indonesian Education University)



Article Info

Publish Date
26 Apr 2026

Abstract

This scoping review analyzes the contemporary landscape of principal-led academic supervision in Indonesia and its implications for instructional quality and educational outcomes. In response to governance decentralization, the Merdeka Belajar reform agenda, and post-pandemic recovery demands, academic supervision has increasingly shifted from regulatory compliance to developmental, reflective, and collaborative leadership practices. Using the PRISMA-ScR protocol, this study systematically identified peer-reviewed empirical studies in Scopus published between 2019 and 2025, resulting in 6 studies that met all inclusion criteria. The synthesis reveals the utilization of diverse models, including clinical supervision, coaching frameworks such as GROW, humanistic- spiritual supervision, and collaborative mechanisms through principal working groups, which consistently demonstrate positive effects on teacher competence, instructional effectiveness, and student engagement. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of these models is constrained by limited supervisory expertise, administrative burden, and disparities in technological and institutional support. The study concludes that strengthening principal preparation, institutionalizing differentiated supervision, and integrating digital supervision tools are essential for enhancing instructional leadership capacity. The review contributes to the field by consolidating fragmented evidence into a comprehensive analytical framework for supervision in developing education systems and by providing strategic recommendations for policymakers, training institutions, and school leaders to reinforce sustainable quality improvement.

Copyrights © 2025






Journal Info

Abbrev

jamp

Publisher

Subject

Social Sciences Other

Description

JAMP : Jurnal Administrasi dan Manajemen Pendidikan [e-ISSN 2615-8574] was first published in 2018 by the Department of Educational Administration Faculty of Education State University of Malang. Published four times a year, March, June, September, and December. We accept research articles within ...