MEJ (Mathematics Education Journal)
Vol. 9 No. 2 (2025): MEJ Vol 9 No.2

Deficit Discourses in Action: Mathematics Teachers’ Attributions of Student Failure in Problem Solving

Chirinda, Brantina (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Dec 2025

Abstract

Student struggles in mathematical problem solving remain a defining feature of South African classrooms. In many cases, teachers respond to persistent student difficulties by attributing them to the students themselves—citing laziness, lack of motivation, or limited ability. This study examined how teacher blaming emerges in classroom discourse and its implications for pedagogical practice. Drawing on interview data from seven South African secondary mathematics teachers, I examined narratives of student failure using attribution theory and critical discourse analysis. The findings reveal that teachers frequently construct failure as an internal, stable, uncontrollable trait of the student. I argue that these blame narratives reinforce deficit thinking and obscure structural, linguistic, and pedagogical barriers to equitable mathematics learning. Findings highlight how deficit narratives sustain inequitable participation, underscoring the need for professional development that reorients teachers' beliefs toward reflective, equity-based pedagogy.

Copyrights © 2025






Journal Info

Abbrev

MEJ

Publisher

Subject

Mathematics

Description

MEJ (Mathematics Education Journal) is a journal that has a mission to publish the results of research, studies and / or innovation of quality in the field of education and learning from all aspects of mathematics education. To accelerate the transfromasi and implementation of science and technology ...