Dirasah: International Journal of Islamic Studies
Vol. 4 No. 1 (2026): Comparative Islamic Studies

Reconceptualizing the Intellectual Revolution: A Comparative Study of Thales and Muhammad

Cecep Sumarna (Siber Syekh Nurjati States Islamic University)
Pendi Hasibuan (Sjech M. Djamil Djambek States Islamic University)
Heri Gunawan (Sunan Gunung Djati States Islamic University)
Fuad Hilmi (Sunan Gunung Djati States Islamic University)
Abdulghani Tehmamad (Fatoni University, Pattani, Thailand)



Article Info

Publish Date
03 Jul 2026

Abstract

This research explores the fundamental epistemological transformation in human consciousness from the dominance of mythos to the emergence of logos through a comparative study of two transformational figures: Thales of Miletus and the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). This research aims to analyze the mechanism of the intellectual revolution initiated by the two figures, compare their models of thought, and examine their impact on civilization. Using a qualitative-comparative approach within the framework of comparative intellectual history, historical philosophy, and hermeneutics, this study analyzes primary and secondary sources to reconstruct these epistemological shifts. The results of the study show that although both figures managed to transition their societies towards argumentative and systematic reasoning, they followed different trajectories. Thales pioneered the rational-naturalistic paradigm by desacralizing the cosmos and seeking material principles (arche). At the same time, Muhammad initiated the rational-transcendental paradigm by integrating revelation, reason, and ethics into a monotheistic epistemology. The main difference lies in the source of its epistemological legitimacy: one is rooted in autonomous human observation and the other in prophetic rationality. This article offers a cross-civilizational approach to intellectual history and provides a new perspective on the plurality of human rationality. Finally, this research proposes a synthesis of civilization that bridges the gap between rationality and spirituality, offering an alternative framework for addressing the modern epistemological crisis through an inclusive, non-Eurocentric dialogue.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

i

Publisher

Subject

Religion Arts Humanities

Description

Dirasah International Journal of Islamic Studies is a double-blind peer-reviewed international journal published by Perkumpulan Dosen Tarbiyah Islam Indonesia (PDTII). The journal publishes research articles, conceptual articles, reports on field studies, and book reviews of Islamic studies (See ...