The Indonesian Journal of Legal Intervention in Social Problems
Vol. 1 No. 1 (2026): The Indonesian Journal of Legal Intervention in Social Problems, May 2026

When Vigilantism Becomes Social Justice: Legal Intervention in Community-Based Punishment in Indonesia

Andi Bangun Sanjaya (State University of Semarang)



Article Info

Publish Date
31 May 2026

Abstract

Vigilante punishment remains a recurring social phenomenon in Indonesia, particularly when communities perceive formal law enforcement as slow, ineffective, or disconnected from local notions of justice. Practices such as collective beating, public humiliation, forced confession, and informal punishment are often justified as necessary forms of community protection. This article examines how legal intervention should respond to community-based punishment without disregarding the social conditions that encourage vigilantism. Using a socio-legal approach, the study analyzes the interaction between formal criminal law, community norms, perceptions of justice, and informal mechanisms of social control. The analysis demonstrates that vigilantism cannot be understood solely as an individual violation of criminal law; it also reflects institutional distrust and the community's demand for immediate justice. The article argues that punitive legal intervention alone may be insufficient and can further distance communities from formal legal institutions. Its contribution lies in proposing a community-responsive model of legal intervention that combines law enforcement, restorative mechanisms, public legal education, and institutional accountability. Such an approach may strengthen access to justice while preventing community-based punishment from becoming an alternative form of unlawful social justice.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

IJLISPRO

Publisher

Subject

Description

The Indonesian Journal of Legal Intervention in Social Problems (e-ISSN: 3164-354X) is an academic journal that published by JUSTISIA GLOBAL EDUKASI two times per year (May & November) in online format. The Journal focuses on the role of law as an instrument for understanding, addressing, and ...