Concrete compressive strength testing is a primary parameter in determining the quality of construction materials; therefore, the reliability of test result data is a crucial aspect of quality control. However, differences in testing conditions among laboratories may lead to variations in test results, which can affect the consistency and reliability of the data. This study aims to analyze the results of interlaboratory comparison of concrete compressive strength tests to evaluate the level of agreement, consistency, and reproducibility of test results as a basis for construction quality control. This research employs a quantitative approach through an interlaboratory comparison involving 10 laboratories in the Special Region of Yogyakarta and Central Java. The test specimens were concrete cylinders with a design strength of fc’ 20 MPa. The analysis was conducted through homogeneity testing, stability testing, and performance evaluation using the Z-score method based on ISO 13528. The results indicate that the test specimens meet the criteria for homogeneity and stability. The performance evaluation shows that all participating laboratories have Z-score values within the acceptable range (|z| ≤ 2), indicating a good level of agreement and consistency in test results. Nevertheless, variations in test values were observed, reflecting differences in deviation from the assigned value among laboratories. These findings suggest that the reproducibility of concrete compressive strength test results among laboratories is generally good; however, potential inconsistencies still need to be addressed. Therefore, the reliability and consistency of test result data are essential in supporting construction material quality control and technical decision-making in construction practices.
Copyrights © 2026