Under Article 1457 of the Indonesian Civil Code, a sale and purchase agreement creates reciprocal rights and obligations between the parties. In Indonesian land law practice, however, transactions involving customary land (tanah ulayat) present legal complexities due to its communal nature and governance by indigenous law communities, coupled with the absence of explicit regulation in the Civil Code and the plurality of customary law systems. This research examines the legal position and juridical implications of tanah ulayat sale and purchase agreements within Indonesian civil law while acknowledging the continued applicability of customary law. Employing a normative legal research method with statutory and conceptual approaches, the study finds that tanah ulayat cannot be directly traded as it is not an object freely transferable under civil law. Legal validity may only arise where the requirements of Article 1320 of the Civil Code are fulfilled and the transaction is preceded by the lawful release of customary rights or a change in legal status with the consent of the relevant indigenous community. Absent these conditions, such agreements lack legal validity and fail to ensure legal certainty.
Copyrights © 2026