Indonesian Journal of Taxation and Accounting
Vol 4, No 3 (2026): September 2026

Improving Internal Control Effectiveness in Accounting Information Systems through Integrated Z-Score, Interquartile Range, and Machine Learning-Based Early Warning Mechanisms

Nano Suyatna (Ma’soem University)
Siti Mialasmaya (Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Pasundan, Bandung)



Article Info

Publish Date
22 Sep 2026

Abstract

Purpose – This study develops and preliminarily evaluates an interpretable hybrid anomaly-monitoring prototype for Accounting Information Systems (AIS) in resource-constrained financial institutions. Internal-control effectiveness is operationalized narrowly as the prototype’s ability to identify and prioritize anomalous transactions for timely human review, rather than as organization-wide control effectiveness. Method – A simulation-based prototype experiment uses a labeled synthetic dataset of 852 transactions. Three univariate detectors applied to transaction value Z-Score (|Z| > 2), Interquartile Range (1.5×IQR), and Isolation Forest are integrated through an explicit rule-based aggregation. Performance is assessed against synthetic ground-truth labels using a confusion matrix and imbalance-aware measures. Findings – The dataset contains 809 normal and 43 anomalous observations. The hybrid classification produced TN=785, FP=24, FN=5, and TP=38, yielding accuracy=0.966, precision=0.613, recall=0.884, F1-score=0.724, specificity=0.970, and balanced accuracy=0.927. The results demonstrate preliminary classification feasibility while indicating a need to reduce false positives. Research implications – The prototype provides interpretable anomaly signals to help authorized reviewers prioritize transactions for further examination; it does not autonomously determine fraud. Originality– The study integrates transparent statistical and machine-learning signals into an AIS-oriented early-warning architecture, defining internal-control effectiveness specifically at the transaction-monitoring level within resource-constrained financial institution monitoring environments.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

IJOTA

Publisher

Subject

Economics, Econometrics & Finance Social Sciences

Description

1. Taxation Tax Policy and Fiscal Policy Tax Compliance and Tax Administration Tax Planning and Tax Avoidance Corporate Taxation International Taxation Digital Taxation and Tax Technology Behavioral Aspects in Tax Compliance 2. Financial Accounting and Reporting Financial Reporting Standards ...