Regulating Legal Ethics in Vietnam: Institutional Challenges, Normative Frameworks, and Reform Imperatives

Minh Tuan Nguyen (Associate Professor and Acting Dean of the Faculty of Theory, History of State and Law, University of Law, Vietnam National University, Hanoi, Vietnam)
Hanh Dang Thi My (Master of law of the Faculty of Theory, History of State and Law, University of Law, Vietnam National University, Hanoi, Vietnam)

Jurnal Cita Hukum
Vol. 13 No. 3 (2025): Winter Edition

This article analyzes Vietnam’s regulatory mechanisms for legal ethics using institutional theory and comparative legal analysis. It explores how ethical standards can move beyond aspirational guidelines to become enforceable norms within a modern rule-of-law system. Applying a normative-analytical approach and case studies from Germany, the UK, the US, and Australia, the study identifies four core pillars of an effective mechanism: (i) ethical standards, (ii) independent supervisory institutions, (iii) transparent disciplinary procedures, and (iv) public accountability. Findings show Vietnam’s framework remains fragmented, administratively dependent, and lacks independent oversight and public participation. Ethical codes are non-binding, while enforcement is internalized, compromising transparency and trust. The article proposes five reforms: interdisciplinary ethical codes, partial legal codification, independent ethics committees, public feedback mechanisms, and situational ethics education. Together, these aim to build a dynamic governance system supporting integrity and accountability in legal practice. This research contributes to debates on regulatory governance in transitional legal systems and offers insights for designing context-sensitive, enforceable ethical frameworks.