The disparity in police accountability effectiveness in Indonesia, Malaysia, and the Philippines demonstrates that the mere existence of oversight institutions does not automatically ensure effective control over police power. This issue is increasingly urgent amid the decline of the rule of law and the growing complexity of transnational crime in the ASEAN region. This study aims to examine why differences in institutional design produce varying levels of accountability effectiveness and to identify the most decisive determining factors. The research employs a normative legal method with a comparative approach, supported by secondary empirical data from institutional reports and global indices. The analysis integrates statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches focusing on institutional structure, authority, and accountability outcomes. The findings reveal that Indonesia produces symbolic accountability due to weak enforcement power, Malaysia achieves moderate effectiveness through procedural balance, while the Philippines faces an accountability paradox caused by institutional fragmentation and weak legal culture. The study confirms that enforcement power, institutional independence, and legal culture are the key determinants of accountability effectiveness. These findings imply the need for institutional reforms oriented toward strengthening binding authority and transforming legal culture. Future research should explore the role of internal actors and political dynamics in shaping oversight implementation.
Copyrights © 2026