Unnes Law Journal : Jurnal Hukum Universitas Negeri Semarang
Vol. 12 No. 1 (2026): Transforming Law and Protecting Rights: Contemporary Issues in Legal Reform an

Scheduled Caste Sub-classification in India after Davinder Singh: Constitutionally Permitted, Doctrinally Incomplete

Karishma Verma (Faculty of Law, University of Lucknow)



Article Info

Publish Date
23 Sep 2026

Abstract

The Supreme Court’s ruling in State of Punjab v. Davinder Singh has revived the debate on sub-classification within the Scheduled Caste category in India, overruling E.V. Chinnaiah and rejecting the premise that a constitutional commitment to equality is satisfied by the formally uniform treatment of groups that are, in fact, internally unequal. Using doctrinal constitutional analysis of the judicial trajectory from M.R. Balaji through Indra Sawhney, E.V. Chinnaiah, and Davinder Singh, this article argues that while sub-classification is constitutionally permissible, the judgment remains doctrinally incomplete in three respects. First, the distinction between identification under Article 341 and benefit distribution under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) is analytically thin. Second, the endorsement of creamy layer logic for Scheduled Castes sits in unresolved tension with Indra Sawhney. Third, the judgment offers no workable standard for judicial review of State-led sub-classification exercises. The article contends that these unresolved issues constitute the principal doctrinal challenge following Davinder Singh and argues that its constitutional promise can be fully realized only through a more coherent framework governing evidence-based, non-exclusionary, and judicially reviewable sub-classification.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

ulj

Publisher

Subject

Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

The Unnes Law Journal is a peer-reviewed scholarly journal that publishes high-quality research on Indonesian law and its interaction with regional and global legal developments. Established in 2012, the Journal aims to advance rigorous legal scholarship and promote evidence-based discourse on law, ...