The enactment of Minister of Finance Regulation Number 168 of 2023 (PMK 168/2023) altered the withholding mechanism for Article 21 Income Tax through an average effective rate scheme, setting the tax base for independent professionals, including physicians, at fifty percent of gross income without accounting for the hospital's and/or clinic's revenue-sharing portion or operational costs. This has drawn objections from physicians, who argue the withholding base fails to reflect the income they actually receive. Using a normative-juridical method with statutory and conceptual approaches, this study examines the provision's conformity with the principle of fairness, the ability-to-pay principle, and the statutory concept of income under the Income Tax Law. Findings show that, formally, the scheme falls within the technical authority to regulate withholding and does not alter annual tax liability. Substantively, however, it risks creating normative disharmony and a liquidity burden for physicians practicing in hospitals and/or clinics, particularly those who have not adopted bookkeeping or the net-income calculation norm. The study recommends requiring transparent, itemized withholding slips that distinguish the physician's actual share from the hospital's and/or clinic's portion, alongside strengthened taxpayer education, so that tax fairness is realized in substance, not merely in form.
Copyrights © 2026