This review evaluates the article "Computational Hermeneutics: Machine Reading and the Epistemology of Literary Interpretation," situating it within the emerging interdisciplinary discourse on artificial intelligence and literary studies. The article advances a theoretically ambitious thesis: that machine reading constitutes not a positivist or anti-hermeneutic practice but a distinctive form of interpretation that both challenges and enriches traditional humanistic hermeneutics. The software code, and even quantified models, has, the article develops three interlocking arguments: that the hermeneutic-positivistic divide in digital humanities is a false dichotomy; that machine reading operates through "interpretive lenses" that shape interpretive attention; and that machine-generated interpretations require renewed engagement with the hermeneutic concepts of situatedness, plurality, and ambiguity. The article's most significant contributions are its rigorous articulation of the epistemological stakes of computational hermeneutics and its nuanced treatment of the "simulated hermeneutic." However, three limitations constrain its impact: an uneven empirical foundation, particularly in its comparative study of human and machine readings; a limited engagement with non-Western and multilingual contexts; and an underdeveloped treatment of power, ideology, and material conditions. The review identifies Habermas's emancipatory interest of hermeneutics of suspicion, and political economy of AI as theoretical resources capable of addressing these gaps. The article ultimately stands as both an important intervention and an invitation to develop an emancipatory computational hermeneutics that integrates critical theory with computational practice.
Copyrights © 2026