Purpose - This study evaluates the effectiveness of mudharabah and musyarakah as interest-free financing mechanisms by examining their Shariah integrity, risk-sharing structure, financial viability, and institutional scalability. It also identifies the structural and operational conditions that support or constrain their implementation within Islamic banking. Design/methodology/approach - A qualitative descriptive-analytical design is employed through library and documentary research within an interpretivist paradigm. Evidence is drawn from peer-reviewed studies, academic literature, regulatory documents, fatwas, and institutional reports. The materials are analysed using document analysis, qualitative content analysis, thematic analysis, and source triangulation to integrate normative, operational, governance, and financial dimensions. Findings - Mudharabah and musyarakah are effective when genuine risk sharing, equitable profit-and-loss allocation, transparency, and contractual integrity are preserved. Their financial viability depends on financing risk, liquidity, monitoring capacity, and institutional quality. Major constraints include information asymmetry, adverse selection, moral hazard, return-smoothing pressures, collateral design, weak financial reporting, limited financial literacy, and uneven Shariah governance. Originality/value - This study distinguishes substantive Shariah effectiveness from financial-operational effectiveness and integrates contractual design, governance quality, information conditions, and financial outcomes within a unified framework. It shifts attention from formal contract classification toward the institutional mechanisms that determine whether partnership-based Islamic financing becomes scalable, credible, and sustainable.
Copyrights © 2025