Purpose – This study develops a theoretically integrated explanation of how the Maqasid Shariah Index (MSI), Sharia Supervisory Board (DPS) effectiveness, and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) performance interact in shaping substantive Sharia accountability and the risk of shariawashing in Islamic banking. It positions maqasid as a transcendent normative foundation, DPS as a governance-transmission mechanism, and ESG as an external accountability layer within a single integrative architecture. Design/methodology/approach – A qualitative narrative-conceptual approach is adopted, deliberately distinct from a formal systematic literature review. Relevant scholarship is synthesized through data reduction, thematic interpretation, and conceptual integration to build mechanistic-deductive propositions linking MSI, DPS effectiveness, and ESG performance. The analysis is constructive-theoretical rather than aggregative-empirical, allowing the study to address three historically separate literature streams that have rarely been integrated. F MSI remains methodologically fragmented because alternative indings –frameworks operationalize maqasid priorities differently. DPS effectiveness determines whether normative maqasid commitments are translated into credible ESG outcomes, with stronger transmission in Social and Governance dimensions than in Environmental. The synthesis further identifies a conditional maqasid–profitability paradox, suggesting that ethical compliance may initially generate organizational costs before becoming a strategic source of trust, legitimacy, and sustainable value. When reported MSI and ESG performance lack substantive DPS governance, shariawashing emerges as a decoupling risk. Originality/value – The principal novelty lies in developing the Extended Stakeholder-Shariah Theory, proposing the U-Shaped Maqasid–Profitability Hypothesis, and introducing the Three-Tiered MSI-DPS-ESG Model as an integrated governance architecture. These contributions reposition maqasid as a transcendent stakeholder reference, DPS as the governance-transmission mechanism, ESG as the external accountability layer, and shariawashing as a decoupling risk. The framework offers policy relevance for regulators, standard-setters, and Islamic banking practitioners, while remaining a propositional model requiring empirical validation.
Copyrights © 2026