Agricultural commodities cultivated under favorable volcanic agroecological conditions may exhibit substantially different economic performance due to variations in production cycles, input requirements, and investment structures. This study compared the economic performance of sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum) and pineapple (Ananas comosus) in the volcanic agricultural region of Mount Kelud, Indonesia, using an integrated Life Cycle Costing (LCC) framework. The analysis combined life cycle cost assessment, economic hotspot analysis, investment feasibility indicators, Equivalent Annual Value (EAV), economic sustainability indicators, and sensitivity analysis. Primary data were collected from local farmers, while secondary data were obtained from agricultural statistics and relevant scientific literature. Sugarcane had a substantially lower life cycle cost than pineapple (IDR 536.62 versus IDR 2,521.08 kg⁻¹), largely because of its ratoon production system. However, pineapple achieved considerably higher annual economic productivity (IDR 139.30 million ha⁻¹ year⁻¹) than sugarcane (IDR 14.25 million ha⁻¹ year⁻¹). Land rental and labor were the main cost drivers for sugarcane, whereas planting material dominated pineapple production costs. Both commodities were economically feasible, with positive net present values, benefit-cost ratios above one, and internal rates of return exceeding the discount rate. Nevertheless, pineapple demonstrated superior profitability and investment efficiency. These findings show that lower life cycle cost does not necessarily indicate better economic performance when production cycles and investment structures differ, providing valuable insights for commodity diversification, investment planning, and farmer resilience in tropical volcanic regions.
Copyrights © 2026