This article stems from the concern that procedural democracy, which is neutral towards truth, has proven vulnerable to a post-truth crisis exacerbated by digital populism in Indonesia. Emotions and identity have replaced facts as the basis for political decision-making, whilst democratic mechanisms are only capable of counting votes without being able to assess the validity of information. It is within this context that Mohammad Natsir’s concept of syura is reconstructed as an epistemological-ethical antithesis. Through a literature review employing a figure-centred analytical approach, this article operationalises Natsir’s theistic democratic framework and Mudde’s theory of populism to dissect three pathologies of the post-truth era: the fabrication of lies, truth relativism, and the void of moral accountability. The results of the analysis indicate that syura, which requires shidq (honesty), haqq (orientation towards truth), and amanah (transcendental accountability), possesses internal mechanisms that directly correct these three pathologies. Vertical accountability to God constitutes the highest point of distinction that is absent in modern democracy. Thus, Syura is not merely a normative legacy, but a relevant conceptual solution for restoring the quality of democracy in the era of digital populism
Copyrights © 2026