Masyarakat, Kebudayaan dan Politik
Vol. 39 No. 3 (2026): Masyarakat, Kebudayaan dan Politik

The instability of belonging: Model minority and security threats among Indian Americans after 9/11 and during COVID-19

Eka Nurcahyani (Faculty of Humanities, University of Indonesia)
Manneke Budiman (Faculty of Humanities, University of Indonesia)
Bayu Kristianto (Faculty of Humanities, University of Indonesia)



Article Info

Publish Date
28 Sep 2026

Abstract

Indian Americans have become more visible in U.S. politics, technology, and public life. However, more prominence in the public eye has not meant secure inclusion. Recognition moments continue to exist alongside suspicion and exclusion, particularly during national crises. This contradicts the assumption that public recognition leads to stable incorporation. This article examines how the model minority stereotype and yellow peril trope have been reconfigured in relation to Indian Americans during the post-9/11 period and the COVID-19 pandemic. It introduces the idea of recursive belonging to explain how increased visibility can lead to both recognition and heightened surveillance. This concept brings together ideas from orientalism, racial triangulation, and proximity to whiteness to create a framework for understanding unstable incorporation. This study uses qualitative critical discourse analysis of media texts, policy documents, and public commentary and shows that public recognition is not the same as unconditional inclusion. Political conformity, class positioning, and dominant racial norms condition acceptance. Caste inequality, political dissent, and cross-racial solidarity are often sidelined or represented as sources of social and political anxiety. Visibility does not answer the question of belonging. The terms of acceptance continue to evolve across political contexts, indicating that substantive inclusion requires structural, not symbolic, change.

Copyrights © 2026