Indonesian Journal of Pancasila and Global Constitutionalism
Vol. 3 No. 1 (2024): January-June, 2024

The Conflict between Legal Certainty and Justice in Court Decisions: An Analysis of Supreme Court Decisions

Zahrotul Widat (Universitas Negeri Semarang)



Article Info

Publish Date
23 May 2026

Abstract

Legal certainty and justice are two fundamental principles in the legal system that play a crucial role in realizing a state based on the rule of law. In law enforcement practice, these two principles often create problems because they are not always balanced. Legal certainty emphasizes the clear, firm, and consistent application of legal rules, while justice places greater emphasis on moral values ​​and the prevailing sense of justice within society. This situation often creates a dilemma for judges when deciding cases, especially when rigid application of legal rules has the potential to lead to injustice for certain parties. This study aims to analyze the application of the principle of legal certainty and examine how judges balance legal certainty and justice in court decisions. This study uses a normative legal research method with a statutory and conceptual approach, conducted through a review of relevant laws and regulations, legal literature, and court decisions. The results show that in deciding a case, judges are not only guided by formal legal rules but also consider the values ​​of justice that exist within society. Therefore, court decisions are expected to provide legal certainty while reflecting a sense of justice within society.

Copyrights © 2024






Journal Info

Abbrev

ijpgc

Publisher

Subject

Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

The Journal publishes cutting-edge peer-reviewed work which refers to and advances global constitutionalism and study of Pancasila as an interdisciplinary field. Submissions are invited from a broad range of disciplines including International Law, Political Science, International Relations, ...