Indonesia’s constitutional order promises to recognize and respect customary law communities, yet the promise has been delivered through a patchwork of sectoral statutes, regional regulations, and judicial corrections that make protection conditional on prior state verification. This article asks why legal recognition has remained partial after more than two decades of constitutional guarantees, and how recognition should be reconceived so that customary law operates as a real instrument of protection rather than as an administrative gateway. Using normative juridical research with statutory, conceptual, and case approaches, the article examines Articles 18B(2) and 28I(3) of the 1945 Constitution, the forestry, agrarian, village, and criminal law regimes, the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court, Government Regulation Number 55 of 2025 on living law, and the 2026 legislative deliberation of the Masyarakat Adat Bill. The analysis shows that Indonesian law recognizes customary communities constitutively rather than declaratively, fragments the criteria of recognition across sectors, and increasingly recognizes adat as a source of sanctions more readily than as a source of territorial and self-governing rights. Drawing on legal pluralism and recognition theory, the article proposes a rights-based, participatory, and pluralist model built on a rebuttable presumption of existence, a harmonized umbrella statute, free, prior and informed consent, regulated adat dispute-resolution institutions, and effective remedies. The article concludes that recognition should be rethought as a duty of the state to protect an existing legal order, not as a favour granted to those who succeed in proving their authenticity.
Copyrights © 2026