This study evaluates the financial performance of Bank Syariah Indonesia (BSI) over 2017–2024 using DuPont analysis and benchmarking against the Islamic and conventional banking industries. The analysis compares the pre-merger and post-merger periods using pooled-period and annual ratios, compelemented by accounting decomposition, exploratory Mann–Whitney U tests, and sensitivity analysis. The pooled profit margin of BSI went up from 9.96% to 23.53%, while the Return on Equity (ROE) increased from 8.41% to 14.05%. However, asset turnover and the equity multiplier went down, which suggests that the better returns for shareholders came mainly from higher margin, rather than from the greater asset utilization or financial leverage. Industry benchmarking further shows that BSI’s relative profit-margin and return-on-equity positions improved compared to both groups, with the mean annual ROE gap shifting from negative to positive in the merger/post-merger period. In contrast, asset turnover and return on assets remained below both industry benchmarks throughout the observation period. The exploratory pre/post differences did not remain statistically significant after Holm adjustment, while sensitivity checks confirmed the direction of the principal findings under alternative aggregation and observation windows. Overall, BSI exhibited stronger profitability and shareholder returns alongside persistent limitations in asset utilization.
Copyrights © 2026