Journal of English Language and Education
Vol 11, No 5 (2026)

Debate-Assisted SSI-PBL: Impact on Students' Critical Thinking, Scientific Attitude, and Academic Stress in Chemistry

Kristiana Dwi Setiani (Universitas Pelita Harapan)



Article Info

Publish Date
16 Sep 2026

Abstract

Critical thinking, scientific attitude, and psychological well-being are essential outcomes of chemistry learning, yet Indonesian students' scientific literacy remains low and classroom practice rarely addresses these dimensions together. Problem-Based Learning integrated with Socio-Scientific Issues (PBL-SSI) narrows this gap, and scientific debate was added because claim-evidence-rebuttal argumentation is theoretically expected to sharpen reasoning and ease academic pressure, yet empirical evidence on this combined approach remains limited. This quasi-experimental study (nonequivalent control group design) examined the effect of debate-assisted PBL-SSI on critical thinking, scientific attitude, and academic stress among 68 twelfth-grade students (experimental n=36, control n=32) using tests, questionnaires, and reflections. Both classes showed moderate, non-significant gains in critical thinking (p=0.151) and scientific attitude (p=0.652), but academic stress decreased significantly in the experimental class and increased in the control class (Cohen's d=-1.567; p=0.000). Debate-assisted PBL-SSI shows practical but statistically unconfirmed cognitive benefits, while robustly reducing academic stress, supporting holistic chemistry education.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jele

Publisher

Subject

Languange, Linguistic, Communication & Media Other

Description

Journal of English Language and Education (pISSN: 2597-6850 and eISSN: 2502-4132) is a journal that focuses on researching or documenting issues in education, language education, applied linguistics, English education, English language teaching, English Literature, language assessment and ...