This study examines the framework for substitute penalties for fines under the National Criminal Code, effective from January 2, 2026, specifically focusing on fine categorization mechanisms, installment payments, and substitute penalties in the form of imprisonment, supervision, or community service. The analysis employs John Rawls's theory of "justice as fairness" and utilizes a normative-juridical method incorporating statutory, conceptual, and philosophical approaches. The findings indicate that the National Criminal Code has enhanced sentencing flexibility by accounting for the defendant's economic capacity, installment payment options, and alternatives such as supervision and community service. However, these mechanisms do not yet fully guarantee substantive justice, as there is a lack of consistent and objective standards for assessing a convicted person's economic capacity, creating a potential burden on those with limited financial means. The study recommends strengthening individual economic assessments, applying the principle of proportionality, and optimizing substitute penalties other than imprisonment. Given the study's normative nature, further research is required to examine practical implementation within court rulings and law enforcement practices.
Copyrights © 2026