Coarse aggregate source is an important but frequently underestimated factor governing the mechanical performance of normal concrete. This study quantitatively compares the compressive strength of normal concrete produced using three locally sourced conventional coarse aggregates, designated A1, A2, and A3, under controlled mixture, production, and curing conditions. Aggregate physical and mechanical characteristics were first characterized, followed by concrete production using a common mix design and standardized specimen preparation. Fresh-concrete workability was evaluated using slump testing, while compressive strength was measured at 7, 14, and 28 days. Descriptive statistics, assumption testing, one-way analysis of variance, Tukey’s post-hoc comparisons, Kruskal Wallis testing, and Pearson correlation analysis were applied to evaluate aggregate-dependent differences. The results demonstrate a persistent strength hierarchy across all curing ages, with A3 producing the highest mean compressive strength, followed by A1 and A2. At 28 days, the mean strengths were 32.82 MPa for A3, 29.10 MPa for A1, and 26.09 MPa for A2. The aggregate source effect was statistically significant (F(2,15) = 24.547, p < 0.001), and all pairwise differences were significant. A3 also exhibited the highest density and lowest water absorption and abrasion loss. Correlation analysis further indicated positive associations between strength and aggregate density, while absorption and abrasion loss showed negative associations. These findings confirm that locally sourced coarse aggregates are not functionally interchangeable and should be quantitatively characterized before concrete production.
Copyrights © 2026