This study examines the comparative analysis of Bitcoin investment in conventional and Sharia financial systems through Jasser Auda’s contemporary Maqashid Shariah systems approach. Amidst massive financial digitalization, Bitcoin triggers debates on positive legal regulations and Islamic legal thought. However, determining its legality faces interpretive challenges due to its abstract and dynamic characteristics. This juridical-normative study uses library research with comparative and conceptual approaches. The results indicate that the conventional system evaluates Bitcoin pragmatically based on market laws. Meanwhile, within Sharia finance, a sharp polarization occurs: MUI declares it haram because its extreme volatility contains gharar and maisir, whereas Muhammadiyah conditionally permits it as mal mutaqawwam due to its blockchain utility. This polarization is rooted in differing viewpoints regarding the absence of physical underlying assets and market risks. Through Jasser Auda’s framework, Bitcoin investment is viewed in a dynamic-contextual manner aligned with the active-regulative protection of wealth (hifdz al-mal). This study recommends limiting investment activities strictly to regulated spot trading by official authorities, and it must be clear from speculative instruments like futures and margin trading to ensure sustainable investment that is legal, ethical, and beneficial
Copyrights © 2026