Ijaz Arabi Journal of Arabic Learning
Vol 9, No 3 (2026): Ijaz Arabi: Journal Of Arabic Learning

Impact of Literal Translation on Arabic Science Textbook Comprehension: A Linguistic Content Analysis

Mohammed bin Jaber Al-Shahri (Universiti Malaya)
Nurazan Mohmad Rouyan (Unknown)
Mahmoud Thabet Ahmed Ibrahim (Unknown)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Jul 2026

Abstract

This study investigates the linguistic quality of translated science textbooks in Arabic-medium education, focusing on the Saudi secondary biology textbook adapted from the American McGraw-Hill series. Translated textbooks in the Arab world often retain the linguistic imprint of the source language, potentially hindering student comprehension. To address this, a 25-indicator content analysis framework was developed based on Gardner’s theory of linguistic intelligence, encompassing five dimensions: vocabulary diversity, structural clarity, rhetorical strategies, interactive activities, and logical sequencing. All nine chapters (268 pages) were systematically analyzed, with inter-rater reliability reaching kappa = 0.87. Results revealed a moderate overall score of 59% (44/75), with logical sequencing performing well (80%), but rhetorical strategies and interactive activities critically low (47% each). Three indicators consistently scored zero: etymological linking of terminology, locally relevant examples, and scientific linguistic games. A total of 387 linguistic problems were identified, dominated by literal translation effects (132 cases, 34.1%). Recurring issues included unnatural prepositional constructions (“biwasitatiha” 200 times), excessively long sentences (40 words), and the absence of cultural references to Saudi, Arab, or Islamic contexts. Teacher interviews (n=6) and student focus groups (n=32) fully corroborated the content analysis, confirming systemic rather than incidental problems. The validated framework offers a replicable diagnostic tool for evaluating translated science textbooks in Arabic-medium settings. Findings highlight the urgent need for culturally contextualized translation practices to enhance science literacy. Limitations include the focus on a single textbook and subject area; future research should extend to cross-national comparisons and explore AI-assisted translation for improved linguistic adaptation. This study contributes to translation studies and science education by demonstrating how linguistic intelligence-based evaluation can inform textbook development in non-Anglophone contexts.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

ijazarabi

Publisher

Subject

Languange, Linguistic, Communication & Media

Description

Ijaz Arabi; published twice a year since 2018 (April and October), is a multilingual (Bahasa, Arabic, and English). This journal is published by the Arabic Department, Faculty of Education and Teachers Training, Universitas Islam Negeri Maulana Malik Ibrahim ...