Journal of Economic Epistemology and Philosophy
Vol. 1 No. 2 (2026): September 2026

Machine consciousness, behaviorist epistemology, and the economics of replacing human roles

Siti Hurul Aini (Perbanas University)



Article Info

Publish Date
10 Sep 2026

Abstract

Whether artificial intelligence (AI) can be conscious is usually treated as a question for philosophers of mind, and the replacement of human labor by AI as a question for economists. This article argues that the two questions are entangled and that their separation is an artifact of the epistemology of modern economics. In a documented corpus of 100 Scopus-indexed records on AI, labor, and morality (2020–2026), responsibility vocabulary appears in 42.6% of 68 retrievable abstracts and consciousness vocabulary in one; an independent query of 11,454 records confirms that consciousness and sentience are rarely discussed (0.7%). A genealogy traces this silence to twin behaviorist turns—revealed preference in economics and the imitation game in computing—that made the economic agent consciousness-agnostic by construction. The article models a human role as functional, agential, and phenomenal layers and defines the phenomenal residual as the unpriced value of a role that depends on its being occupied by a subject of experience. A schematic welfare account yields three propositions: consciousness enters private substitution decisions only insofar as it is priced; unpriced residuals create a wedge toward excessive automation; and, because AI instances can be copied cheaply, even small credences in machine sentience can dominate social evaluation. A counterpoint from Islamic legal and economic thought supports a principle of non-delegable answerability, and five principles for a consciousness-sensitive economics under Knightian uncertainty conclude the article.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

JEEP

Publisher

Subject

Description

Journal of Economic Epistemology and Philosophy (JEEP) is an international scholarly journal dedicated to publishing high-quality academic works that examine the philosophical, epistemological, ethical, historical, and theoretical foundations of economics and economic thought. The journal aims to ...