Journal of Law and Justice
Vol. 1 No. 3 (2026)

HIV/AIDS as a National Security Threat: Narrative Construction and the Limited Empirical Basis of Global Security Policy

Shakina Aisya Rahma Ismail (Universitas Hasanuddin)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Sep 2026

Abstract

This study examined how HIV/AIDS was constructed as a national and international security threat and assessed whether the resulting security claims were proportionate to the available empirical evidence. A qualitative document-review design was used, combining purposive literature selection with critical content analysis of policy documents, United Nations materials, global health reports, and peer-reviewed research. The analysis operationalized securitization through the identification of securitizing actors, referent objects, audiences, threat claims, and policy consequences. The findings showed that the security framing of HIV/AIDS was driven particularly by concerns about state stability, military readiness, and peacekeeping operations. However, the empirical relationship between HIV/AIDS and state failure or international insecurity was indirect, context-dependent, and frequently mediated by poverty, conflict, governance capacity, and health-system resilience. Securitization increased political attention and resources, but it also risked threat inflation, stigma, and policy displacement. The study concluded that security considerations should remain subordinate to evidence-based, rights-sensitive, and public-health-oriented HIV policy.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jlj

Publisher

Subject

Description

Journal of Law and Justice (E-ISSN : 3163-7183) adalah jurnal ilmiah yang memuat hasil penelitian, kajian konseptual, serta pemikiran kritis di bidang hukum. Jurnal ini menjadi wadah bagi akademisi, praktisi hukum, peneliti, dan mahasiswa untuk mempublikasikan karya ilmiah yang berkontribusi ...