Correct answers in chemistry assessments do not always reflect adequate conceptual understanding, particularly when students engage with different forms of chemical representation. This issue is important because students may successfully solve problems without constructing appropriate conceptual explanations. This study investigated the distribution of Conceptual Understanding (CU), Transitional Understanding (TU), Procedural Knowledge (PK), and Misconception (MC) across macroscopic, submicroscopic, and symbolic representations in chemical kinetics. It also examined the association between representation types and understanding categories and explored aggregate patterns related to pseudo-understanding. A descriptive and associative quantitative design was employed with 254 Grade 11 students. Data were collected using 14 three-tier diagnostic test items, generating 3,556 responses. Data analysis included descriptive statistics, 10,000 restricted within-student permutation tests, Cramer’s V, and Correspondence Analysis (CA). The results showed that PK was dominant in macroscopic representation (35.6%), TU was highest in submicroscopic representation (28.0%), and MC and PK occurred equally in symbolic representation (27.4% each). CU showed a relatively stable distribution across representations (20.9–23.1%). Although representation and understanding category were significantly associated (χ²(6) = 44.778, pperm < 0.001), the association was very weak (Cramer’s V = 0.079; inertia = 0.013). The findings indicate that correct answers may occur without adequate conceptual reasoning and support the need for diagnostic assessments that evaluate students’ reasoning and confidence alongside answer accuracy.
Copyrights © 2026