International Journal of Science and Society (IJSOC)
Vol 8 No 4 (2026): International Journal of Science and Society (IJSOC)

The Duty to Give Reasons for the Length of Substitute Imprisonment for Replacement Money: An Analysis of Decisions No. 36/Pid.Sus-TPK/2022/PN Plk, No. 2/PID.SUS-TPK/2023/PT PLK, and No. 3802 K/Pid.Sus/2023

Gaudensia Erika Deru Erap (Universitas Kristen Artha Wacana, Kupang, Indonesia)
Ibrahim Yakob Michael Laa (Universitas Kristen Artha Wacana, Kupang, Indonesia)
Liven Erfelis Rofael (Universitas Kristen Artha Wacana, Kupang, Indonesia)



Article Info

Publish Date
01 Nov 2026

Abstract

Substitute imprisonment for payment of replacement money in corruption cases is subject to a maximum limit, but no indicators guide the selection of its duration. This normative legal study uses statutory and case approaches to describe the rules governing judges’ duty to give reasons, assess the reasoning of the District Court and High Court in the Bumi Jaya village-budget case, and explain the scope of the Supreme Court’s review on cassation. The analysis is qualitative and deductive, based on three indicators: whether reasons are given, whether a legal basis is identified, and whether the decision is accurate and correct. The duty to give reasons derives from Article 50(1) and Article 53(2) of Law No. 48 of 2009. The District Court imposed one year of substitute imprisonment without specific reasons; the High Court reduced it to eight months on the basis of a sense of justice without specifying a measure; and the Supreme Court dismissed the cassation appeal without discussing the duration. The absence of guidelines does not eliminate the duty to give reasons.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

ijsoc

Publisher

Subject

Materials Science & Nanotechnology Social Sciences

Description

International Journal of Science and Society (IJSOC) is open access and peer-reviewed journal with e-ISSN (2715-8780), IJSOC is an international journal devoted to the study of science and technology in a social context. It focuses on the way in which advances in science and technology influence ...