Al-Istinbath: Jurnal Hukum Islam
Vol 11 No 2 (2026): Inpress

Islamic Jurisprudence and International Science Governance: A Comparative Analysis of Normative, Procedural, Institutional, and Outcome Compatibility

Mahmood Jawad Abu-AlShaeer (Al-Rafidain University College)
Abdulsatar Shaker Salman (Al-Mansour University College)
Saif Saad Ahmed Ahmed (Al-Turath University)
Gulsara Kuldysheva (Osh State University)
Olesia Romanenko (Kyiv National University of Construction and Architecture)



Article Info

Publish Date
23 Oct 2026

Abstract

International science governance increasingly operates across legal systems, raising questions about the compatibility of international regulatory standards with Islamic jurisprudence. This study examines the conditions under which Islamic legal principles can inform science governance without undermining scientific freedom, institutional autonomy, individual rights, or legal certainty. Employing a comparative legal approach, the research combines doctrinal analysis, structured legal coding, secondary quantitative indicators, and longitudinal policy analysis. It examines Malaysia, the United Arab Emirates, Turkey, Indonesia, and Saudi Arabia during 2010–2024, focusing on intellectual property, bioethics, environmental responsibility, data governance, research integrity, and international scientific cooperation. The findings identify four dimensions of compatibility: normative, procedural, institutional, and outcome compatibility. Normative convergence is evident in the protection of life, intellect, justice, public welfare, environmental responsibility, and research accountability. However, shared ethical objectives do not necessarily establish procedural or institutional compatibility. Conflicts arise when religious interpretations acquire binding authority without clear legal authorization, scientific expertise, procedural safeguards, or independent review. The comparative findings suggest that hybrid governance arrangements are more legally defensible when jurisprudential consultation operates alongside scientific assessment, clearly defined institutional responsibilities, and effective rights protection. The study proposes a four-dimensional compatibility framework that distinguishes ethical convergence from enforceable legal integration. It concludes that Islamic jurisprudence can contribute to international science governance through transparent legal reasoning, institutional accountability, and proportionate regulatory arrangements rather than unrestricted religious oversight.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

alistinbath

Publisher

Subject

Religion Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

Al-Istinbath : Jurnal Hukum Islam, is an academic journal focuses on Islamic Law studies and aimed to accommodate and socialize innovative and creative ideas from researchers, academics, and practitioners who care in the field of Islamic Law. The focus of this journal is an effort to load scientific ...