Problem-based learning (PBL) can foster critical thinking, but open-ended problem solving, delayed reflection, and unequal participation may limit consistent reasoning practice. This study aimed to develop structured reflective problem-based learning (SR-PBL) and evaluate its needs basis, expert validity, practicality, and preliminary implementation in environmental education for pre-service Madrasah Ibtidaiyah teachers. A pragmatic research-and-development design integrated classroom observations, a lecturer interview, course-plan review, self-assessments from 174 students, expert appraisal, practicality testing, and a nonrandomized pretest-posttest comparison involving three SR-PBL classes (n = 85) and one conventional PBL class (n = 28). The course plan covered 51.3% of the targeted components; expert ratings ranged from 64.81% to 87.22%; worksheet practicality was 79.50% and comprehensibility was 86.67%. SR-PBL classes improved by approximately 6.2 points compared with 2.32 points in the comparison class, with Hedges' g = .98. The findings support the feasibility and further refinement of SR-PBL; however, low test reliability and the use of nonrandomized intact classes preclude confirmed causal-effectiveness claims
Copyrights © 2026