Small-scale fisheries in tropical coastal regions lose substantial catches to inadequate cold storage infrastructure, and no structured decision framework addresses this gap. The trade-offs among economic, technological, and environmental criteria resist intuition. Using AHP-TOPSIS, we evaluated four cold storage design alternatives against seven criteria grouped under three pillars (Economics, Technology, Environment). Pairwise judgments remained consistent, with the highest sub-level Consistency Ratio reaching 0.008 (Technology pillar). The prefabricated polyurethane panel with rooftop cooling (A2) ranked first (CC = 0.6266), followed by conventional masonry (A1, 0.5662), modular steel with IoT monitoring (A4, 0.5265), and insulated concrete with solar-hybrid cooling (A3, 0.3330). Sensitivity analysis showed A2 winning 91.4% of scenarios; A4 outranked A2 when either the IoT-readiness weight (C3) exceeded 0.21 or the investment-cost weight (C1) fell below 0.20. Despite the lowest-carbon profile, A3 ranked last under cost-dominant weights, a structural green penalty against the most sustainable design. Cooperative ownership can move the optimum toward IoT-enabled A4 by pooling capital that individual operators cannot mobilize alone.
Copyrights © 2026