Journal of Management and Innovation Entrepreneurship (JMIE)
Vol. 4 No. 1 (2026): October

SELECTING COLD STORAGE BUILDING DESIGNS FOR TROPICAL SMALL-SCALE FISHERIES: AN AHP-TOPSIS DECISION MODEL

Muhammad Alfathan Harriz (Matana University)
Harlis Setiyowati (Budi Luhur University)
Inggit Musdinar (Budi Luhur University)
Hari Soetanto (Budi Luhur University)
Nurhaliza Vania Akbariani (Budi Luhur University)



Article Info

Publish Date
31 Oct 2026

Abstract

Small-scale fisheries in tropical coastal regions lose substantial catches to inadequate cold storage infrastructure, and no structured decision framework addresses this gap. The trade-offs among economic, technological, and environmental criteria resist intuition. Using AHP-TOPSIS, we evaluated four cold storage design alternatives against seven criteria grouped under three pillars (Economics, Technology, Environment). Pairwise judgments remained consistent, with the highest sub-level Consistency Ratio reaching 0.008 (Technology pillar). The prefabricated polyurethane panel with rooftop cooling (A2) ranked first (CC = 0.6266), followed by conventional masonry (A1, 0.5662), modular steel with IoT monitoring (A4, 0.5265), and insulated concrete with solar-hybrid cooling (A3, 0.3330). Sensitivity analysis showed A2 winning 91.4% of scenarios; A4 outranked A2 when either the IoT-readiness weight (C3) exceeded 0.21 or the investment-cost weight (C1) fell below 0.20. Despite the lowest-carbon profile, A3 ranked last under cost-dominant weights, a structural green penalty against the most sustainable design. Cooperative ownership can move the optimum toward IoT-enabled A4 by pooling capital that individual operators cannot mobilize alone.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jmie

Publisher

Subject

Decision Sciences, Operations Research & Management Economics, Econometrics & Finance Environmental Science Social Sciences Other

Description

Journal of Management and Innovation Entrepreneurship (JMIE) is a national journal as a scientific study media results of research, thinking, and critical-analytical studies on research in the fields of marketing management, financial management, SDM management, operations/production management, ...