Reform of Indonesian criminal procedure raises questions about evidentiary sufficiency and the limits of judicial discretion when statutory provisions no longer reproduce earlier formulations of minimum proof. This study examines the relationship between evidentiary requirements and judicial conviction under Law Number 20 of 2025 on Criminal Procedure and develops a framework for evaluating the reasoning underlying findings of guilt. It adopts a normative legal method using statutory and conceptual approaches, with legal materials examined through systematic interpretation and legal argumentation. The analysis indicates that changes in statutory wording do not, by themselves, establish the abolition of evidentiary safeguards or authorize unrestricted judicial discretion. Judicial conviction must remain grounded in lawfully obtained evidence, reasoned assessment, and respect for the prosecution’s burden of proof. The study proposes an evidence-quality evaluation framework encompassing legality, authenticity, relevance, reliability, relationships among items of evidence, relevant alternative explanations, and the adequacy of judicial reasons. This framework treats judicial conviction as a conclusion requiring justification rather than an independent substitute for proof. It offers a conceptual basis for reconciling judicial independence with accountability while preserving the presumption of innocence. Its contribution remains normative; whether the framework improves consistency or reduces erroneous decisions requires subsequent empirical testing.
Copyrights © 2026