Policy & Governance Review
Vol 10 No 3 (2026): September

Administrative Justice in Public-Sector Automated Decision-Making Governance: A Systematic Review

Setiawan Setiawan (Public Policy at the Graduate School of Universitas Lancang Kuning, Pekanbaru, Indonesia. )
Hernimawati Hernimawati (Public Policy at the Graduate School of Universitas Lancang Kuning, Pekanbaru, Indonesia.)
Trio Saputra (Public Policy at the Graduate School of Universitas Lancang Kuning, Pekanbaru, Indonesia.)



Article Info

Publish Date
02 Nov 2026

Abstract

Public authorities are increasingly embracing automated decision making (ADM). The literature on legal mandates, organizational practice, and citizen results is mixed. This systematic review assesses the conceptualization of accountability, transparency, supervision by humans, and administrative justice in public sector ADM by scholarship and how protections are operationalized. The search in Scopus (PRISMA method) resulted in 122 entries and 56 qualifying full-text papers. The archive is dominated by doctrinal and socio-legal research (28/56) and European contexts (31/56). Conceptual and case studies are many but empirical qualitative [7] and quantitative [5] are limited. The gap between ideals and implementation is stark: literature describes more than safeguards for review, correction, and repair ADM governance ideals. Three conflicts are clearly emerging: formal accountability versus diffused responsibility, formal transparency versus useable cures, and formal oversight by humans versus intervention capacity. A four-layer diagnostic methodology is proposed: system traceability, administrative capability, institutional responsibility, and citizen-facing remedies. Cross-layer dependency matters: safeguards cannot work without complementary records, authority, review capability, or accessible remedies.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

pgr

Publisher

Subject

Decision Sciences, Operations Research & Management Social Sciences Other

Description

This journal encompasses issues and practices in policy analysis, public management, public policy and administration. PGR provides high quality study outcomes and new thoughts for academic practitioners, researchers, scientists and consultants to discuss about social science theories and concepts ...