Al-Sharf: Jurnal Ekonomi Islam
Vol 7, No 3 (2026)

Zakat Policy Resistance: A Hybrid Approach of Systematic Literature Review and Bibliometric Analysis

Selfi Hastria Ningsih (STAI AR RISALAH SUMATERA BARAT)
Hardi Putra Wirman (Sjech M. Djamil State Islamic University Bukittinggi)
Novi Hendri (Sjech M. Djamil State Islamic University Bukittinggi)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Oct 2026

Abstract

This study aims to map the structural landscape of scientific publications, identify cross-disciplinary intellectual frameworks, synthesize specific behavioral manifestations of community resistance, and uncover deep-rooted research gaps concerning resistance to formalized state zakat policies. Methodologically, this study implements an innovative hybrid systematic approach combining bibliometric mapping via VOSviewer and a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) guided strictly by the PRISMA 2020 protocol. Out of 158 raw articles initially extracted from the Scopus database as of October 12, 2026, a final sample of 34 rigorous peer-reviewed articles met the precise multi-stage inclusion criteria after rigorous screening for duplication, document type restrictions, and exhaustive full-text qualitative eligibility. Results: Bibliometric visualization identifies a heavy geographic polarization centered in Southeast Asia, designating Indonesia and Malaysia as the ultimate global research epicenters, with the Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research emerging as the absolute central multidisciplinary hub. The systematic qualitative review reveals that public policy resistance is distinctly separate from the rejection of fundamental religious obligations; instead, it manifests structurally as severe institutional mistrust, deep-seated digital transformation barriers, parallel operation of unpermitted local grassroots agencies, regulatory tax-deduction bottlenecks, and strong friction against aggressive legal enforcement. Ultimately, this study concludes that policy compliance or friction is an interactive result of normative-religious alignment, subjective social pressures, perceived distributive justice, administrative complexity, and state-enforced legitimacy.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

Mudharib

Publisher

Subject

Economics, Econometrics & Finance

Description

Al-Sharf: Journal of Islamic Economics published by the Rahmat Islamiyah Foundation, Medan, Indonesia. In this journal the articles contain articles about the fields of Islamic scientific research and Islamic education. Al-Sharf: Journal of Islamic Economics received manuscripts in the field of ...