Jurnal Suara Keadilan
Vol. 27 No. 2 (2026): Jurnal Suara Keadilan Vol. 27 Nomor 2 (2026)

KONSTRUKSI DAN REPOSISI DISKRESI PENGHENTIAN PENYIDIKAN TINDAK PIDANA PERPAJAKAN PASCA KUHAP 2025

Pierre Canry Rambe Manalu (PKN STAN)



Article Info

Publish Date
30 Oct 2026

Abstract

The termination of tax crime investigations under Article 44B of the Indonesian General Provisions and Tax Procedures Law reflects the tension between fiscal recovery and criminal accountability. Although the mechanism is frequently associated with ultimum remedium, the fulfilment of fiscal requirements does not automatically terminate an investigation because the final decision remains with the Attorney General. This study examines the legal character and limits of such decision-making authority and formulates its repositioning within the criminal justice system following the enactment of the 2025 Criminal Procedure Code. This research employs a normative legal method with statutory, conceptual, and historical approaches, supported by grammatical, systematic, teleological, and historical interpretation. The study finds that ultimum remedium primarily explains the policy orientation of Article 44B, while the decision to discontinue an ongoing investigation is more closely associated with the opportunity principle. It also identifies a regulatory asymmetry: fiscal eligibility requirements are relatively detailed, whereas substantive and procedural parameters for the final decision remain insufficiently structured. Accordingly, this study proposes a three-tier model consisting of a Fiscal Eligibility Test, a Substantive Criminal Interest Test, and a Procedural Accountability Test. The model preserves fiscal recovery as the central objective of Article 44B while strengthening proportionality, legal certainty, and accountability in the exercise of decision-making authority.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

SK

Publisher

Subject

Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice

Description

Fokus dan Scope artikel yang bisa dimuat dalam jurnal ini adalah: 1. Ilmu Hukum 2. Hukum Pidana 3. Hukum Perdata 4. Kebijakan Publik 5. Politik Hukum 6. Hukum Ekonomi ...