Expert testimony plays an important role in the criminal justice system. The expertise of expert witnesses in their respective fields when providing testimony is a strong piece of evidence in helping judges reach their decisions. In essence, expert testimony is neutral and objective, and its purpose is to help clarify a criminal act. This study examines the role of expert testimony in criminal procedure law theory and practice, particularly regarding the objectivity of testimony as mandated by law. This study is a normative study using a conceptual, legislative, and comparative approach. The results of the study show that there is a tendency for expert testimony to be biased and partial. By examining the mechanism of expert testimony in England, this study discusses the need for reform in the Indonesian criminal justice system in order to uphold justice and legal certainty. There is an urgent need to reconstruct the role of expert testimony in the criminal justice system so that expert testimony is not merely a means of fulfilling the minimum requirements for evidence for judges in making a decision, but rather expert testimony should serve as an enlightening source for decisions to achieve the fairest possible outcome within the framework of legal certainty.
Copyrights © 2026