This article examines the household as an arena of negotiation between family law, the labor market, and social policy in Indonesia. Although the female labor force participation rate continues to rise, family law norms particularly Article 31 paragraph (3) and Article 34 of the Marriage Law and Articles 79 and 80 of the Compilation of Islamic Law continue to position the husband as head of the family and breadwinner, while the wife is cast as a housewife. The internal ambiguity of the law reveals a formal recognition of equality while simultaneously locking in gender-based role division. Consequently, when women enter the labor market, the domestic burden does not decrease but rather increases, while a gender-segmented labor market and social policies that exclude informal workers fail to provide women with a sufficiently strong threat point to renegotiate their roles. The state, through its social policies, actually reinforces the old norms instead of acting as a neutral third party. Within the gaps of the law, women develop alternative negotiation strategies such as self-censorship, conditional transparency, tactical persuasion, and delegation of domestic tasks that enable substantive autonomy without openly challenging the existing hierarchy. Using a juridical-normative approach and prescriptive-analytical analysis, this article concludes that family law reform is insufficient if it merely recognizes formal equality; it must create a framework that enables equal negotiation, including recognition of care work, redistribution of domestic burdens, and inclusive social policies.
Copyrights © 2025