This study examined changes in speaking scores following instruction using printed mass media among tenth graders at SMAN 1 Sakra. It used a pre-experimental one-group pretest–posttest design. The article was developed from the undergraduate thesis and a reanalysis of 35 paired scores in its appendix. Instruction used earthquake-related reading materials to support comprehension, discussion, and oral presentation. Recalculated pretest and posttest means were 29.71 (standard deviation 13.61) and 35.14 (standard deviation 12.22), respectively. The mean difference was 5.43 recorded score units, with a 95 percent confidence interval from 0.41 to 10.45. The paired t-test yielded t(34) = 2.197, p = .035, and a standardized within-participant change of 0.37. Twenty students obtained higher scores, nine were unchanged, and six declined. These results differ from the thesis’s descriptive summary but reproduce its main hypothesis-test output. The findings indicate a positive within-group change, while a causal effect of printed media remains unestablished because no verifiable comparison group is available. Unclear score conversion and insufficient documentation of rating consistency further limit interpretation. Printed materials warrant structured classroom use and more rigorous evaluation rather than an unqualified effectiveness claim.
Copyrights © 2024