This study compares descriptive-writing creativity scores following What–Why–How instruction and mind mapping at SMA Negeri 1 Seteluk. A quasi-experimental pretest–posttest design involved two Grade XI classes of 30 students each. Each group received six instructional meetings during April–May 2022. Students completed a 60-minute task describing physical appearance and character, assessed through idea fluency, flexibility, and elaboration. The article recalculates individual scores from the results tables because the thesis abstract presents conflicting summaries. The What–Why–How mean increased from 55.67 to 79.17, while the mind-mapping mean remained 53.17. The posttest difference of 26.00 points yields Welch’s t(45.64) = 12.16, p < .001, with a 95% confidence interval of [21.69, 30.31]. These values agree with the main results tables rather than the contradictory abstract figures. The findings show a substantial difference on the administered task and rubric. However, one class per condition, insufficient rater-reliability documentation, and unresolved construct validity limit causal interpretation. The study does not establish improved general creativity or show that mind mapping is inherently ineffective. Replication should include several classes, independent ratings, and transfer tasks.
Copyrights © 2024