This study compared Predict–Organize–Search–Summarize–Evaluate (POSSE) and Predict–Locate–Add–Note (PLAN) strategies in teaching English reading competency to eleventh-grade students at MA At-Tahzib. A two-group pretest–posttest design involved 30 students in class XI B receiving POSSE and 30 in class XI C receiving PLAN. The thesis reported pretest means of 78.47 and 65.67 for the POSSE and PLAN groups, respectively, and posttest means of 82.60 and 78.10. Corresponding within-group mean changes were 4.13 and 12.43 points. Although the original report presented a statistically significant independent-samples test, the inferential table did not align with its reported posttest means. This article therefore distinguishes the descriptive findings from an unverified between-group significance claim. Both strategies were associated with higher posttest averages, but the baseline imbalance and inconsistent statistical reporting prevent a definitive conclusion about their relative effectiveness. The findings highlight the value of structured comprehension activities and transparent analysis of classroom intervention data.
Copyrights © 2024