This study described debaters’ critical thinking skills and reading strategies among four members of the Executive English Debate Community (E2DC) at Universitas Pendidikan Mandalika. A descriptive qualitative case-study approach was employed. Data were collected through online observation of a British Parliamentary debate and a questionnaire covering cognitive reading strategies and the incorporation of critical thinking in reading. The observation classified the Opening Government participant as excellent, Opening Opposition as average, Closing Government as good, and Closing Opposition as below average. Questionnaire findings indicated that cognitive-domain reading strategies were more prominent than explicit critical-thinking incorporation for all four debaters. The findings suggest that drawing information from news texts for argument construction does not necessarily entail equally strong evaluation of evidence, inference, and justification. Because the study involved only four active participants and did not include an intervention or pretest–posttest comparison, the results are descriptive rather than evidence of improvement.
Copyrights © 2024