Jurnal Sipakatau
Vol. 3 No. 6 (2026): October

Securitization, Critical Security Studies, and Human Security: A Sequential Analysis of Indonesian Citizens in Transnational Online Scam Syndicates

Andika Zanuar Ramadhan (Program Pascasarjana STIK-PTIK Angkatan 16, Widya Endra Dharmalaksana, Jakarta)



Article Info

Publish Date
25 Oct 2026

Abstract

This study examines how the Copenhagen School, Critical Security Studies, and Human Security can be applied sequentially to explain the construction of security threats, the distributional consequences of security practices, and the identification of the appropriate referent object in Indonesia’s contemporary security policy. The study employs a qualitative theoretical-comparative design based on literature review and document analysis. The primary case concerns the protection of Indonesian citizens involved in online scam syndicates in Cambodia during 2025-2026, while the securitization of online gambling and the escalation of national cyber threats are used as comparative cases. Academic literature, legislation, official institutional documents, international reports, and verified media reports are analysed through a sequential theoretical framework. The Copenhagen School explains how an issue is constructed and accepted as a security threat, thereby legitimizing measures beyond routine policy responses. Critical Security Studies reveals how security practices should also be assessed in terms of power relations, status-determination procedures, and the distribution of security and insecurity. Human Security subsequently shifts the analytical focus toward individuals and their economic, personal, and community vulnerabilities as the ultimate referent objects of security. The online scam case demonstrates that victimhood and criminal involvement may overlap, making protection and law enforcement analytically inseparable. Rather than treating the three approaches as competing theories, this study proposes a sequential interpretation: securitization explains how an issue becomes a security threat, Critical Security Studies asks for whom security practices operate, and Human Security identifies who should ultimately be protected. For the Indonesian National Police, a transition toward human- and community-centered policing requires not merely enhanced enforcement capacity, but also transparent identification procedures, citizen-oriented performance indicators, and cross-jurisdictional mechanisms capable of reconciling protection with legal accountability.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

Sipakatau

Publisher

Subject

Religion Arts Humanities Computer Science & IT Engineering Environmental Science Health Professions Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice Library & Information Science Mathematics Nursing Physics Social Sciences Veterinary Other

Description

1. Social Sciences, Economics, Psychology, Tourism, and Community Development Coaching and mentoring for leadership, performance improvement, and community empowerment Psychological and behavioral dimensions of community programs including motivation, behavior change, and ethics Volunteerism ...