This article re-examines limitation of prosecution and of the execution of sentences in Indonesian criminal law. Limitation is usually justified by legal certainty, deteriorating evidence, and procedural efficiency, yet applied uniformly it can protect offenders who commit serious crimes. The study is doctrinal (normative) legal research using statute, conceptual, comparative, and case approaches, analysed qualitatively through Radbruch's triad of justice, legal certainty, and utility. Findings on existing rules: (1) limitation is a policy limit on the state's power to punish and not an absolute value; (2) legal systems follow no single pattern, since England and Wales apply no general limit to indictable offences, Germany and the Netherlands combine tiered periods with exclusions for the gravest crimes, and Islamic criminal law has no general limitation; (3) Articles 132 and 136 to 143 of Law No. 1 of 2023 classify offences by maximum penalty alone and say little about flight, concealment, or victim vulnerability. Normative proposal: one classification rule, resting on a paradigm in which justice resides in the judge (Qur'an, At-Tin [95]: 8), with prospective application and fair-trial safeguards. Limits: the model is a reasoned proposal and not a legislative text. The article recommends three tiers, namely six years for very light offences, a default period extended to twenty years for serious offences, and imprescriptibility for the most serious offences, and it treats execution only as a linked framework that is not fully drafted.
Copyrights © 2026