Journal of Law, Administration, and Social Science
Vol 6 No 6 (2026)

Reconstructing the boundary between business loss and state financial loss in state-owned enterprise management: Good corporate governance and directors' fiduciary duty after Law Number 16 of 2025

Javas Mesa Briantama (Universitas Gadjah Mada)



Article Info

Publish Date
02 Nov 2026

Abstract

Law Number 1 of 2025 and Law Number 16 of 2025 reshape the relationship between state-owned enterprise (SOE) losses and state finances. Article 4B treats gains or losses as those of the SOE, while Article 9F codifies a conditional business judgment rule (BJR). Yet the criminal-law boundary remains unsettled where a business decision causes loss. This normative legal study uses statutory, conceptual, and case approaches to develop a six-parameter fiduciary loss attribution test: informed process, loyalty, legality of authority, good faith and corporate purpose, mitigation, and loss qualification. It examines Constitutional Court Decisions Nos. 48/PUU-XI/2013 and 62/PUU-XI/2013, Decision No. 28/PUU-XXIV/2026, and cases concerning Karen Agustiawan’s BMG investment, the LNG Corpus Christi transaction, Hotasi Nababan, and the 2025 ASDP acquisition. The central doctrinal argument is that Article 36(2) of the Criminal Code permits punishment for negligence only where legislation expressly provides for it, whereas Articles 603 and 604 do not formulate negligence as a punishable mode; Article 604 also requires an intention to obtain an unlawful benefit. Accordingly, a serious procedural failure alone cannot replace proof of the statutory mens rea. The test is proposed as an interpretation of unlawfulness and culpability, not as an additional element of an offence. It differentiates ordinary procedural defects, acts beyond authority, and abuse of authority for an improper purpose, while preserving civil and administrative accountability where criminal elements are not established.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

jolas

Publisher

Subject

Humanities Economics, Econometrics & Finance Environmental Science Law, Crime, Criminology & Criminal Justice Social Sciences

Description

Journal of Law, Administration, and Social Science merupakan media penyebarluasan hasil penelitian di rumpun ilmu sosial, ilmu politik, dan humaniora. Sub rumpun Ilmu sosial terdiri dari bidang Ilmu Komunikasi, Jurnalistik, Hubungan Masyarakat, Periklanan, Televisi dan Film, Manajemen Komunikasi dan ...