Studies of al-dakhīl fī al-tafsīr (illegitimate elements in Qur’anic exegesis) have mostly examined narrative, scientific, and theological verses, while verses bearing on political and religious authority have not been examined thematically with explicit criteria. This article maps forms of al-dakhīl in the interpretation of six such verses (Q 1:6; 2:1–2; 2:204 and 2:207; 4:59; 9:36; 33:40) as read in Imāmī Shiite exegesis (Tafsīr al-Qummī, al-Burhān, and readings attributed to al-Mīzān), in Kharijite readings reported in heresiographical and historical sources, and in Ahmadi commentary. Using qualitative content analysis, the study applies the typology of al-dakhīl bi al-riwāyah and al-dakhīl bi al-raʾy, together with five criteria that distinguish al-dakhīl from legitimate disagreement (ikhtilāf), and compares each reading with classical Sunni exegesis as an openly stated frame of reference. Four recurring mechanisms were identified: reliance on reports with problematic transmission (one case), narrowing a general meaning to a specific referent (three cases), symbolic reading of numbers (one case), and lexical shift (one case). Two cases fall under al-dakhīl bi al-riwāyah and four under al-dakhīl bi al-raʾy. The case of ulī al-amr shows that a sectarian reading does not become dakhīl merely because it differs from the majority; it does so when one possible meaning is made exclusive and is derived from doctrine rather than from the text. The distinction between the Qadian and Lahore branches of the Ahmadiyya likewise shows that the label applies to specific interpretive moves, not to whole communities. The article offers verification criteria applicable to other politically charged interpretations.
Copyrights © 2026