Setyaki : Jurnal Studi Keagamaan Islam
Vol. 4 No. 3 (2026): AGUSTUS

Otoritas Kharismatik dan Tata Kelola Profesional di Pesantren: Pembagian Ranah Operasional dan Strategis dalam Kepemimpinan Kyai

Asfiatul Hamidah (Universitas KH. Mukhtar Syafaat Blokagung)



Article Info

Publish Date
19 Oct 2026

Abstract

The professionalisation of pesantren governance is often framed as a threat to the authority of the kyai, yet the division of domains between the two is rarely examined empirically. This article asks how charismatic authority and professional governance operate together in one Islamic boarding school, PPMT King Abdul Aziz in Banyuwangi. The earlier version of this manuscript announced a comparison across "several pesantren with different leadership typologies"; that claim is withdrawn, because the data were collected at a single site. Using a qualitative single-case design, data were gathered from 20 informants (kyai, board of advisers, administrators, students, alumni) through in-depth interviews, participant observation and documentary study, and analysed with the interactive model of Miles and Huberman. Three findings emerge. First, professionalisation operates at the operational level: a formal structure with job descriptions, a management information system, and periodic financial reporting. Second, charismatic authority is retained at the strategic and value-setting level: informants state that principled decisions still require the kyai's direction, which is held to be "not only rational but also spiritual". Third, resistance arises not against professionalisation as such but against the fear that it will erode traditional values, and it is distributed unevenly across units. Read through Weber's notion of the routinisation of charisma, the case shows that charisma is not displaced by bureaucratisation but relocated to the domain where legitimacy is produced.

Copyrights © 2026






Journal Info

Abbrev

setyaki

Publisher

Subject

Religion

Description

SETYAKI invites scholars, researchers, and students to contribute the result of their studies and researches in the areas related to Islam, Muslim society, and other religions which covers textual and fieldwork investigation with various perspectives of law, philosophy, mysticism, history, art, ...