Environmental degradation complicates migrant return decisions by requiring authorities to assess future harm under conditions of uncertainty. This article examines how environmental evidence should inform the application of non-refoulement within the international legal framework available through 2023. Normative legal research employs treaty, conceptual, and case approaches, focusing on the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, relevant Human Rights Committee interpretations, and Teitiota v. New Zealand. The analysis distinguishes evidence of an environmental hazard from proof of a legally relevant risk upon return. It finds that assessment must connect destination conditions with individual exposure, vulnerability, access to protection, and reasonably foreseeable consequences. General country information and personal evidence perform complementary functions, while scientific uncertainty neither automatically establishes nor defeats a claim. The article develops an evidence matrix and a structured reasoning framework for evaluating environmental return risks. It concludes that effective assessment requires transparent links between evidence, factual findings, and the applicable legal threshold, supported by review capable of preventing irreparable harm. The proposed framework is doctrinal and does not predict eligibility or replace examination of individual circumstances.
Copyrights © 2023