Sentencing repeat theft offenders requires courts to reconcile individual responsibility, public protection, proportionality, and the statutory requirements governing recidivism. Differences in imprisonment terms raise concerns about consistency, but they do not independently establish unjustified disparity. This article examines the legal framework for evaluating such differences in relation to Jambi District Court decisions. It employs normative legal research through statutory and conceptual approaches, supported by published case analysis and sentencing scholarship available through 2024. The discussion distinguishes repeated offending as a factual history from recidivism satisfying Article 486 of the Criminal Code applicable during that year. It also separates an increased statutory maximum from the sentence selected in an individual case. A published discussion of a Jambi theft judgment provides a local illustration, without constituting an independently verified comparative dataset. The analysis argues that disparity must be assessed through comparable offences, documented criminal histories, individual participation, victim harm, and reasoned treatment of aggravating and mitigating circumstances. It proposes a structured framework for examining judicial decisions. Consistent sentencing requires transparent justification rather than automatic sentence uniformity, while conclusions about actual local disparity require comparison of complete and verified judgments.
Copyrights © 2024